| 1963 | Sterling Slaughter | P | First-Team |
| 1964 | Skip Hancock | P | Second-Team |
| 1965 | Luis Lagunas | 2B | First-Team |
| Rick Monday | OF | First-Team | |
| John Pavlik | P | Second-Team | |
| 1967 | Gary Gentry | P | First-Team |
| Scott Reid | OF | First-Team | |
| 1968 | Fred Nelson | 2B | First-Team |
| 1969 | Billy Cotton | C | Second-Team |
| Larry Gura | P | First-Team | |
| Paul Ray Powell | OF | First-Team | |
| 1970 | Lenny Randle | SS | Third-Team |
| 1971 | Alan Bannister | SS | First-Team |
| Roger Schmuck | 1B | First-Team | |
| Craig Swan | P | Third-Team | |
| 1972 | Eddie Bane | P | First-Team |
| Alan Bannister | SS | First-Team | |
| Craig Swan | P | First-Team | |
| 1973 | Eddie Bane | P | First-Team |
| Bill Berger | 2B | Third-Team | |
| 1975 | Jerry Maddox | SS | First-Team |
| 1976 | Mike Colbern | C | First-Team |
| Ken Landreaux | OF | First-Team | |
| John Poloni | P | Second-Team | |
| 1977 | Hubie Brooks | OF-SS | First-Team |
| Dave Hudgens | 1B | Second-Team | |
| Bob Horner | 2B | First-Team | |
| Rick Peters | OF | Third-Team | |
| 1978 | Chris Bando | C | First-Team |
| Hubie Brooks | OF-SS | First-Team | |
| Bob Horner | 2B | First-Team | |
| 1981 | Kevin Romine | OF | First-Team |
| Mike Sodders | 3B | First-Team | |
| 1982 | Alvin Davis | 1B | Second-Team |
| Kevin Romine | OF | Third-Team | |
| 1983 | Oddibe McDowell | OF | First-Team |
| 1984 | Oddibe McDowell | OF | First-Team |
| Todd Brown | OF | Third-Team | |
| 1985 | Barry Bonds | OF | First-Team |
| 1987 | Mike Benjamin | SS | First-Team |
| 1988 | Kevin Higgins | 2B | First-Team |
| Linty Ingram | P | Second-Team | |
| Dan Rumsey | OF | First-Team | |
| 1989 | Mike Kelly | OF | Second-Team |
| John Finn | 3B | Third-Team | |
| 1990 | Mike Kelly | OF | First-Team |
| Anthony Manahan | SS | First-Team | |
| Sean Rees | P | First-Team | |
| 1991 | Mike Kelly | OF | First-Team |
| 1993 | Paul LoDuca | C/DH | First-Team |
| Antone Williamson | 3B | First-Team | |
| Marc Barcelo | P | First-Team | |
| 1994 | Jacob Cruz | CF | Second-Team |
| Antone Williamson | 3B | First-Team | |
| 1995 | Ryan Bradley | P | First-Team Freshman |
| Robbie Kent | 1B | Third-Team | |
| Cody McKay | 3B | Honorable Mention | |
| Kaipo Spencer | P | Second-Team | |
| 1996 | Robbie Kent | 2B | Third-Team |
Webmaster T.J. Brewster & Ty Brewster